Di Maggio’s Pizzeria

Reviews

• Steven S.

  star star star star star 25 June 2026

  Local spot offering delicious pizza! Finally I found a decent pizzeria. The prices are fare & the food is good. Small spot located inside a strip mall w/ plenty of parking & limited indoor seating.
  
  The pizza was not too thin & not too doughy. The sauce was flavorful & the cheese was cheesy. The best part is the sesame crust.

• Cecily J P.

  star star star star star 22 June 2026

  Pizza is amazingggg! Ever since my fiancé began watching the YouTube series -Bar Stool with Dave who gives reviews on pizzas, we have been so motivated to try our own pizzerias nearby. This place has an amazing sesame seed crust that makes the pizza even more delicious. The cheese and sauce are so good! This is our usual spot! Never disappoints

• Angela R.

  star star star star star 21 June 2026

  Needed a place that would deliver. This was referred to me through a mom group. Service was fast and pizza was excellent.
  We never get delivery bc it's usually cold by the time it gets here but this was hot and fresh. Will come again,
  For people with dietary restrictions there is sesame seeds on their regular pie crust.

• Matthew K.

  star star star star star_border 14 June 2026

  "Do you remember those days hanging out at the Village Green?" Fun fact: Billy Joel is referencing this part of town when he's singing in "Italian Restaurant", so it's only appropriate to have eaten at an awesome pizzeria in this part of Levittown. My family was looking for a great place to grab a slice of pizza nearby, and some very happy Yelp reviews brought us to Di Maggio's Pizzeria. With one person in the group having never eaten a real slice of NY pizza, we were hoping this place would live up to the hype. Fortunately, the pizza here really is delicious and offers that classic NY flavor we were hoping to find.
  
  Di Maggio's is a small pizzeria but that doesn't stop the folks here from serving up a tasty slice of neapolitan or sicilian. Among the 3 pizza-eaters in the group, we ordered a plain slice, sicilian slice and bbq chicken slice. My wife claims it was the best bbq chicken pizza she had! Meanwhile, the pizza-newbie LOVED his plain slice. I also really enjoyed my slice of sicilian. It was doughy with just the right amount of crunch and had a great sweet flavor between the sauce, cheese and crust. Yum!
  
  Otherwise, Di Maggio's really is your traditional Long Island pizzeria. The service is quick, the ambiance is modest, and the choices are both varied and cheap.
  
  If you're in Levittown, Hicksville, or even Wantagh, consider giving Di Maggio's a try. It's a great pizzeria in the heart of Long Island!

• Zaneta O.

  star star star star_border star_border 4 June 2026

  Picture this scene....You walk into a new pizza place you've never tried before. First impressions are it's a bit old fashioned and no frills but sometimes some of the best joints usually are. You think to yourself... "this place has potential."
  
  There's only one other customer inside and he just began eating his lunch. You walk up to the counter and place your order for pepperoni pizza and then you take a seat and begin to fiddle with your phone. You loose track of time and the other customer is now giving you strange looks as he clears off the remnants of his devoured lunch.
  
  No one has approached the counter for quite some time yet you hear chatter in the back room from afar. You begin to wonder "How long have I been sitting here?" and just as the thought crossed your mind the other customer exclaims "I think they forgot about you" just as he walks out the door.
  
  You promptly stand and march towards the counter with conviction as your hunger grows stronger. The employee gives you a wave as you can suddenly see in his eyes that he realizes that he just burned your pizza. He apologized and threw a new one in the oven this time he stayed up front likely so he would not be distracted a second time.
  
  This time the pizza was pulled out of the oven promptly and it was on the house since the first one burned. A very nice gesture indeed. Once I actually tasted it I must say it was pretty good. It was sesame crust but a lot of the sesame had fallen off but enough was still prevalent for me to get the flavor. The sauce is on the sweet side. The cheese and pepperoni are both tasty. It's quite oily however. You can tell by the amount of oil on the plate in the pic and I hadn't even folded it yet.
  
  Is it worth driving to? Probably not, but it's still a solid spot for a slice overall. Just be sure to make your presence unforgettable.